The James Patterson McBaine Honors Moot Court Competition is Berkeley Law’s highly-esteemed, advanced-level appellate competition. Now in its sixth decade, McBaine is a beloved Berkeley Law tradition that is as gratifying as it is intense. Beyond a mere contest, McBaine is designed to both test and hone written and oral advocacy skills as participants independently prepare an appellate brief and deliver at least two oral arguments. The competition is modeled after United States Supreme Court practice, with each student assigned to represent either Petitioner appealing the lower court’s decision or Respondent opposing the appeal. Each year, the competition problem is selected from real appellate decisions involving cutting-edge issues of great public importance.
On March 31, 2020, we will welcome Chief Judge R. Guy Cole, Jr. of the United States Court of Appeals for the Sixth Circuit; Judge Stephen Higginson of the United States Court of Appeals for the Fifth Circuit; and Judge Allison J. Rushing of the United States Court of Appeals for the Fourth Circuit to preside over the final round. We are honored by and very grateful for their commitment to our students.
For more information about competition format, eligibility, and application process, see below.
This advanced-level competition historically has only been open to Berkeley Law second- and third-year JD students. This year, for the first time, we are proud to expand the competition to include students in both the Traditional Track and the Thesis Track of the Berkeley Law LL.M. program. See the names of McBaine winners and finalists over the years.
Additional Information for Competitors:
- Application/Registration Request Form
- 2020 Competition Rules (forthcoming)
- 2020 Competition Calendar (forthcoming)
- 2020 Competition Record (forthcoming)
- 2020 Commitment Form (including side preference and schedule conflicts) (forthcoming)
- 2020 Brief Scoring Rubric (forthcoming)
- 2020 Oral Argument Scoring Rubric (forthcoming)
- Frequently Asked Questions
- Helpful Materials (including winning briefs from past years)
Students receive the Record ahead of Winter Break, submit their briefs in February, and deliver oral arguments in late March. Judges, Berkeley Law faculty, and practitioners evaluate both the briefs and the preliminary oral arguments. Students advance to the quarterfinals, semi-finals, and the final round based on their performance on the brief and in the preliminary rounds of oral argument, with the brief counting for at least half of the available points in the earlier rounds. Prizes are awarded for the best oral argument and for the best brief for Petitioner and Respondent, respectively.
While students participating in McBaine attend information sessions covering the fundamentals of brief-writing and oral argument and may consult with both the Student Directors and the Academic Director throughout the competition, they receive minimal guidance and are strictly forbidden from receiving any outside help–including from fellow students–when writing their briefs. Students may receive minimal stylistic feedback while preparing for oral argument.
Each year, we host a panel of esteemed judges from the state and federal bench as they preside over the final round of oral arguments. Because all members of the law school community are welcome and encouraged to attend, our two McBaine finalists typically present their arguments before a robust, attentive audience.
Past final round judges have included Supreme Court Justices Stephen Breyer and Sonia Sotomayor; D.C. Circuit Judge David Tatel; Seventh Circuit Judge Diane Wood; Ninth Circuit Judges Marsha Berzon, Morgan Christen, William Fletcher, Sandra Ikuta, Mary Murguia, and Paul Watford; Northern District of California Judges Charles Breyer, Edward Chen, Jon Tigar, and Claudia Wilken; Middle District of Georgia Judge Leslie Abrams Gardner; New York Southern District Judge J. Paul Oetkin; California Supreme Court Justices Kathryn Werdegar, Carol Corrigan, Goodwin Liu, and Leondra Kruger; Alaska Supreme Court Justice Daniel Winfree; and many others. Semifinal round judges have included justices and judges of the California Court of Appeal and Superior Court, as well as a number of other federal court judges.
The McBaine Competition and Best Brief Award are made possible with generous support from Crowell & Moring LLP.