FACULTY > The Dog that Did Not Bark

The Dog that Did Not Bark: No-Citation Rules, Judicial Conference Rulemaking, and Federal Public Defenders

By Stephen R. Barnett

Website Appendix

62 Washington and Lee Law Review, 1491 (2005)

IV. Positions Taken by Forty-Seven Active or Senior Ninth Circuit Judges Favoring, Opposing, or Failing to Comment on Proposed Rule 32.1:

A. Thirty-Eight Judges Who Filed Comments Opposing the Rule:
Alarcon
Bea
Beezer
Berzon
Boochever
Browning
Bybee
Callahan
Canby
Farris
Ferguso
Fernande
Fisher
William Fletcher
Goodwin
Graber
Holcomb Hall
Hawkin
Hug
Kozinski
Leavy
McKewn
Dorothy Nelson
Thomas Nelson
Noonan
O'Scannlain
Paez
Reinhardt
Rymer
Silverman
Skopil
Sneed
Tallman
Thomas
Thompson
Trott
Wallace
Wardlaw

B. One Judge Who Filed a Comment Favoring the Rule:
Tashima